|
Foreword:
· Many professionals in the field of finance believe that it is the
potential benefits which offshore trusts can provide which has sparked
the growth in offshore business as a whole and which has enabled the
majority of centres to develop their finance sectors and
infrastructures. The reader should not mistake an offshore company with
an offshore Trust, even though they are a few similarities on the day to
day running and duties but the reader will during this session realise
that the trustees duties ( subject to the terms of the Trust )
expands much further than one could possibly imagine.
Definition of a Trust
A precise definition of a trust is difficult as there are so many
variances but generally speaking it is the relationship which exists
when a person, called the trustee, is compelled in equity to hold
property, called the trust property, for the benefit of persons, called
the beneficiaries.
The person who creates a trust is
usually referred to as the settlor or in some countries he is
called the grantor (e.g. USA). The settler could be a beneficiary and
even the trustee of his own trust.
There can be more than one trustee and
in some cases a trust protector may be appointed, whose role would
usually be to oversee the actions of the trustees and make sure that the
settlor's intentions in establishing the trust are met.
The trustee will have a number of duties
and responsibilities which he will be required to fulfil and will also
be granted certain powers over the property under his control. If a
trustee carries out an action which he should not have done or fails to
perform a task which he should have carried out, he might be in breach
of trust, a situation which all trustees must try to avoid.
The trust is a common law vehicle and
the trust legislation which you will find in offshore centres will be
derived from UK trust statutes and precedents. Although each centre
which offers trust services will have its own trust laws, many of the
main principles and concepts will be the same.
Creation of a Trust
Trusts can be created in a variety of ways but students are only
required to be familiar with the most common methods.
Express Trusts
An express trust is created as a result of a positive, intentional
action on the part of the settler, such as him executing a trust deed or
other such instrument to create an intervivos (during your
lifetime) trust (which is the name given to a trust created during the
settlor's lifetime). Another example of an express trust is a
testamentary trust, the terms of which are contained in a person's will
and which only comes into force on the testator's death.
The majority of offshore trusts are
intervivos express trusts.
Implied Trusts
These are created as a result of what the law infers as being a person's
intention. There are two main types of implied trust, resulting and
constructive.
Resulting Trusts
This could arise following a transfer of property from A to B without
any indication that a gift was intended or has taken place. The property
would be held on a resulting trust for A, as on B's death the property
would revert (be transferred back) to A. Similarly, A could transfer
property to B to hold for C's lifetime. If there is no instruction as to
what is to happen to that property on C's death the property would be
held on a resulting trust for A, as on C's death the property would
return to A (or A's estate if he too had died).
Constructive trusts
These are trusts which are imposed by the courts and occur where it
would be inequitable for a person to be considered to hold property for
his sole benefit. An example of this would be where a matrimonial home
has been purchased in the name of the husband but both he and his wife
contributed to the value. In such a case the husband would hold he
property as trustee and he and his wife would be the beneficiaries.
Statutory Trusts
These are trusts which come into force as a result of the operation of a
statute, such as those created under the intestacy succession rules in
the UK.
Legal Entity
Students should be aware that a trust is not in itself a legal entity,
unlike a company. It is the trustees who are the legal owners of the
trust property and it is they who would be the party to a legal action
involving the trust property.
It is because of this that certain types
of trust assets, such as quoted investments and realty, are not usually
registered in the name of a trust but instead are registered in the name
of the trustees of the trust.
The Legal Requirements for a Valid
Trust
For a trust to be effective and hopefully meet the objectives for which
it has been created (we cover the uses of trusts in the next Section) it
must meet certain legal requirements. If it fails to meet these
requirements it would generally be considered to be invalid and would
not take effect or be deemed to have ever existed. This could have
disastrous consequences for the settlor and possibly the trustee.
The following is a summary of the
requirements which must usually be fulfilled to enable a trust to be
considered valid. Once again, we shall concentrate on the main areas
which students should be aware of and leave some of the more 'technical'
arguments and theories to other texts.
Capacity of the Settlor
Generally speaking, any person over the age of majority, which in most
countries is 18 years of age, who has the capacity to manage his own
affairs, can create a trust.
Purpose of the Trust
A trust must not attempt to promote immorality, restrain marriage,
separate a parent and child or generally be for a purpose which is
considered illegal or against public policy. It is also usually improper
to make an immediate gift which is subject to a permanent restriction or
alienation.
The Three Certainties
The three certainties must also be present for a trust to be valid and
these can be summarised as follows:
Certainty of subject matter
The property which will be transferred into and subsequently held in the
trust must be clearly identified in the trust deed. Often a trust is
created with only a nominal amount of trust property, such as ?100, and
additional assets will then be transferred to the trustees at a later
date.
If there is no certainty of subject
matter, a trust cannot be created as a proper transfer of property has
not taken place between the settler and the trustees. The result is that
any property which would otherwise have been used to create the trust
will remain the property of the client.
Certainty of objects
It must be certain who is to benefit under the terms of the trust and
also what the nature and extent of their benefit will be. The trust deed
should therefore specify who the beneficiaries will be and also the
nature of their benefit (e.g. discretionary, life interest etc). If it
is uncertain who is to benefit, the trust will fail and the property
will be held by the trustees for the settler on a resulting trust.
Charitable trusts and non-charitable
purpose trusts do not have to meet this certainty as we shall see later
in this study text.
Certainty of words
It must be certain from the wording of the trust instrument or deed that
it was the intention of the settler to create a trust. Expressions by
the settler which suggest he wished or desired to create a trust should
be avoided. If there is uncertainty concerning the intention to create a
trust, the transferee will take any property transferred to him
absolutely as the owner (i.e. the 'trustee' would take the property
which would otherwise have been held by him on trust).
Properly Constituted
The settler must make sure that he completes the transfer of the
intended trust property to the trustees. If he fails to complete all
that is necessary to effect this transfer, such as failing to sign a
stock transfer form to transfer an investment asset into the name of the
trustees, then the trust is said to be incompletely constituted and will
not be valid.
Trust Duration
In most centres there is a requirement (Panama and the Turks and Caicos
being the notable exceptions) that trust property must vest (or be
transferred to or held for a beneficiary) within what is termed the
perpetuity period. If the property is not vested within that time the
trust would generally fail.
The maximum period for which vesting may
be postponed is usually referred to as the perpetuity period and starts
from the creation of the trust. Some trust deeds refer to this period as
the trust duration period.
The length of the perpetuity period of a
trust will vary depending upon the offshore centre chosen. However, many
centres have chosen the options available under English trust law which
is either the period of a life in being plus 21 years or, as is more
usually the case, a specific number of years not exceeding 80.
Possible Uses of an Offshore Trust
Possible Tax Planning Opportunities
In theory the main tax planning opportunity which a trust creates is
that the settler would cease to be the owner of the trust property and
therefore not subject to tax on those assets. Instead, it would be the
trustees who, in theory, would be liable to pay tax on the trust's
income and realised gains.
If the trust is located in an offshore
centre (which will impose either no or low rates of tax) there can
therefore be considerable tax saving opportunities available.
Family Succession Planning
A trust can be used to enable a settler to make financial provisions for
himself, his spouse and his family (or indeed others) during his
lifetime and also after his death.
Provision for Those Who Cannot Manage
Their Affairs
A trust can also be used to make provision for those who, through
whatever reason or incapacity, are unable to look after their own
financial affairs. The individuals concerned would usually be included
in the trust deed as beneficiaries but would only receive distributions
at the discretion of the trustees.
Similarly, a trust can be used to
protect family funds from spendthrift members of the family. The person
concerned would usually be entitled to receive the income from the trust
fund but with no entitlement to the capital.
Asset Protection
A trust can be used to protect a person's assets from local government
agencies or authorities who might have the power to freeze or
expropriate assets of citizens or residents of that country. If the
assets are not held by a citizen or resident of that country (i.e. they
are owned by offshore trustees) they could be protected from this
particular line of attack.
A trust can also be used to protect
property from the claims of forced heirs and in some cases from future
creditors, both uses we shall return to in Unit 11.
In addition, a client might own a
particular asset which he would like future generations of his family to
enjoy or benefit from. Such as asset could be the family home, a
valuable work or art or shares in the family business. A trust can be
created to hold the asset with restrictions imposed relating to the
disposal of the property.
To Avoid Probate Problems
A trust can also help solve the probate problems which we discussed when
looking at the use of companies. Although at this time, the assets would
be in the name of the trustees instead of the company.
Protection from Creditors
Some offshore trusts can be used to protect an individual from the
claims of future, unknown creditors.
To Cover Emergencies
A trust could be used as a contingency planning vehicle to provide cover
in the event of an emergency. For example, a client could put in place
the paperwork and transfer of assets to create a trust which would only
be activated on the happening of a particular event, such as his
incapacity or perhaps kidnap!
Once activated, the client's assets
would be managed by the trustees and his family would continue to be
provided for.
To Provide Greater Confidentiality
A trust is a confidential arrangement between the settler and the
trustees with minimal or, in the majority of cases, no reporting
requirements. Indeed, often the beneficiaries will not know of the
existence of the Trust under which they have given an interest.
Some trusts are created without the
settler being party to the trust deed which increases the secrecy
element. This would usually involve the trustee executing a deed under
which he would declare that he was holding the specified trust property
in accordance with the terms as set out in the deed. This is commonly
referred to as a declaration of trust.
A variation of this theme, although not
necessarily advisable is the situation where a trust deed is executed by
a person who is referred to as the settler in the deed but who is in
fact acting on the instructions of another party. The person who creates
the deed is essentially a nominee or 'dummy settlor' whose purpose is to
conceal the true identity of the settler. |